Eclipse SPF50+ in PerfecTint Beige is a lighter shade than Extreme Protect SPF40 in PerfecTint Beige. To further distinguish between the two tints, Eclipse PerfecTint Beige is a cooler shade best for fair to light skin tone with cool/red undertones, while Extreme Protect SPF40 in PerfecTint Beige is a warmer shade best for light to medium or olive skin tone (Fitzpatrick II-IV) with yellow undertones.